Skip to content
Scope Urban Blog

A Plan to Reform the Academy Programme and Help Young Footballers

Among my favourite moments from the campaign occurred recently, viewing a promising starlet charge up the pitch from his own 18-yard line to score a decisive finish.

Homegrown talents are invariably appreciated by their club's fans and, based on my observations, the fanbase are likely to enjoy many more exceptional moments from him in the years to follow.

But, for a single player who makes it, there are thousands of other youngsters who fail to progress through the different phases, and have to cope with a devastating setback at a formative age.

It is these players who fall away of academy football that are my focus, because I don't think the current setup is sufficient to inform them about their odds, or care for them when they are discarded.

It demands an overhaul and, when I left management, I authored my own report into the youth development pathway, with recommendations for how it could be enhanced.

An Massive Outlay – With Some Major Returns

The viewpoint on academies is more than as a former manager. My family members are in the programme, so I've got a vested interest too.

For all young footballers, the goal of becoming a professional player is a unique one. The academy system has been created to give them the optimal chance to achieve that dream, with a specific initiative being introduced over a decade ago.

Right now, thousands of boys are in the setup, at teams from the Premier League down. It's an all-encompassing structure, with coaching no less than three nights a week and a games programme that consumes most of their weekends.

The same model is now being adopted by the fastest-growing sport, girls football, too.

These academies are staffed at exceptional levels and create work for coaches, physiotherapists, medical staff and many more administrative staff.

The facilities are of the top level, with world-class indoor and outdoor fields. Academic study is provided too, with tutors hired to run compulsory academic programmes.

The investment is immense but, as we have seen, the clubs at the top end are gaining significant returns on that spending through loans and transfers of the academy-produced players.

What is the status of the Present Plan?

The main performance programme has been in effect for around 15 years now, so how has it fared to the test of time?

Academies now operate a pre-academy programme for children from the age of six, so if any of them see through the entire programme they would graduate at 21. That's longer than a child spends in mainstream education, and spans his entire childhood.

These children are given with club kit and jackets, all branded up, and are seen by friends and family as being part of that club.

Their identity has, practically, been imprinted on them at a young age and they also have to make a full dedication to the academy programme.

That means training on three nights a week, and a games programme lasting most of the weekend, are now part of a young player's journey to pursue his dream.

From my findings, in a lot of cases what happens at their studies is seen as being a lower priority, with the academy becoming dominant and becoming the primary preoccupation of the child and his parents' life.

Certain families see a financial reward at the end of the journey if their child makes it and put enormous stress on their shoulders to succeed.

Unfortunately, data show the system has a total imbalance of achievement and failure. We all see the stars, but we seldom see those who don't succeed.

We Must Be Honest About Their Odds

I have no desire to take those aspirations away from aspiring players but we need to be realistic with them about their chances.

While there are specific talents a club will identify as being potential professionals, the reality is many of the players have only been on the pathway to occupy the places needed for coaching and the weekend games at each age group.

I really believe academies adequately manage the hopes of these players or families, about where they stand in the overall system.

Players and parents should be given a comprehensive assessment of where they stand, so they can plan for the inevitable letdown when it arrives.

Our academies have nurtured some fantastic talent and there is increased attention paid to player welfare now than in the past, but let's also bring in a bit more emphasis on transparency too.

Greater Focus on Education

As I noted above, I feel many youth players joining academies often pay more attention of their coaches at times than they do of their teachers.

It's important this is understood within the academy system, and academy directors relay this directive to the coaches at each age group.

This phenomenon itself is nothing new. Mentoring played a massive part in my youth, and sports teachers and coaches were always held in great esteem.

But, for anyone running an academy, they must ensure the coaches are given clear direction and awareness of their role because of the impact they have.

Standards of respect, discipline and hard work should be as demanding as they are in any educational environment – and should extend to the educational side of the child's life there too.

The system I have proposed would have greater weight on studies and guidance – for guardians as well as the young players – and also support for what follows if they are let go aged 16.

The Plan to Assist Young Footballers

I would structure academies within several zones, each overseen by a head and link them with accredited schools and colleges.

Before they get to scholarship level, players would be reviewed at 14 to see what learning pathway suits them.

At 16, players starting apprenticeships would begin in a required integrated education programme with the academic partners.

At the same time, the players who are let go at 16, can commence a full-on dual academic programme with the schools or colleges.

The advantage for them would be the establishment of a independent competitive programme where the schools and colleges would

The writer

Paul Myers

Urban planner and lifestyle writer passionate about sustainable city living and community development.

Scope Urban Blog

Type to search articles.